spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Which route to take?

2004-11-12 11:31:19
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

We're having an IRC discussion and discussing what we should do about organizing in that forum as well as here on the list... what follows are some comments/thoughts I had while in IRC... since IRC is pretty fleeting and this seems an important discussion to me I wanted to send them to the list as well.

<csm-laptop> peoples behavior will continue to be as it has been... this should not dissuade us from setting and following a viable course... so to me the real question continues to be...

<csm-laptop> to organize, or not. if so... what scope and structure we apply seem to me to be the point of our discussion up to this point of digression

<csm-laptop> some people say just SPF steering... PHB is saying make it an accountable standards group to match SPF's status as the current defacto standard...

<csm-laptop> I happen to agree with him....

<csm-laptop> because I believe that if we fail to fill this void someone else will... that would waste the resource we have as the inarguable top dog in this space right now

<csm-laptop> and if we give someone a wedge point they will use it.

<csm-laptop> M$ proved that during the IETF debacle...

<csm-laptop> if someone wants to say we're "forking" the IETF then let them... personally I think a little competition in the standards place would be very useful...

<csm-laptop> though I don't hold myself up as a shining example of leadership with respect to SPF (I really cannot code my way out of a wet paper sack) I will not take a back seat to anyone as an implementor... thus I can easily see what needs to be done and do it and after more than 20 years doing administration I think I have a good grasp on what a "standard" is and should be

added afterwards: *AND* I think that SPF *IS* already a standard though there is no organized party shepherding it as of now.

<csm-laptop> if WE do not impose our will in this space then someone else will impose theirs on us... it *IS* that simple and if we do not carpe this here diem we will have lost what is undoubtedly the best and greatest opportunity we have had thus far to make a real difference

<csm-laptop> So... am I arguing for the larger scope? you bet... because for reasons stated above I believe it is our best chance for success!

- --
csm(_at_)moongroup(_dot_)com, head geek
http://moongroup.com
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.1 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFBlQF6v6Gjsf2pQ0oRAkS9AJ9fDAslnu2S+8XErHE0N9o+vy7HbwCcCPJW
wsMcR7avz95gbNzevbcbcQc=
=u7Dc
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • Which route to take?, csm <=