ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Issues relating to managing a mailing list...

2012-03-15 12:04:36
Is this really a big enough problem to be worth solving? I can't
recall a single instance where I received IETF list with a problematic
attachment.

i travel to places with very poor bandwidth.  it is a problem.

and the vast majority of users just do not get it.  "we send 20mb
documents around the office all the time.  suck it up."


for who has problem in attachment downloading the solution should be
at the delivery Message Store level, where the strip of the attachment 
could be
done accordingly to an user configurable mailbox parameter
(as we do on our server, where we call it Easy Delivery).

Or better still, don't strip anything. Use a reasonably capable client and
that doesn't fetch attachments unless you tell it to.

Yes, I agree, but we can leave the end user to choose accordingly their own 
no capable/capable clients or maybe accordingly to temporary condition.

I'll again note that implementation of this policy will cause people to send
single part messages in order to avoid attachment stripping, which will make 
it impossible for clients to avoid downloading material they do not want. 

I think that a part in a single part message can be replaced as any other part 
in a multipart message.

In other words, it will exacerbate, rather than solve, the problem.

                              Ned

Francesco