I don't think we have seen an adequately strong argument
for requiring it, i.e., including it as profile information in the
charset name, although we have gotten close.
[...]
Read what I said again. "Likely to be desirable in many cases". "No
adequately strong argument for requiring...".
OK, I now see that we don't differ. (I probably don't need to provide
a lame excuse again, but I'll do so anyway: I was reacting
specifically to the part of your message that said "although we have
gotten close".)
Anyway, good to see that we agree as usual.
Regards,
Erik