ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Multipart/Mixed and Compound Documents

1993-03-22 13:38:49


Notes to you all:

1) X.400 systems, especially PC-net gateways, routinely create
   body parts without a trailing CRLF. The user usually neither knows
   nor cares, and therefore will not attach semantics to it.
   However, when gatewaying X.400 into MIME, it would be improper to
   add the "missing" CRLF just because we suppose we know better than
   the end-user. So, defining huge semantic meaning for it is NOT
   a Good Thing, IMHO.

2) Doesn't anyone but me get the willies when considering something that
   behaves much like a character (like Nathaniel's smileys) being introduced
   by 6 lines of separators, bodypart identifiers and the like?
   I *still* think that MIME should *not* be a compound document standard,
   but a way to ship "relatively" large pieces of info around, on the
   order of one image or one letter. NOT one smiley.
   (the ultimate solution to Chinese: Send each CHARACTER as a MIME
   PostScript body part, and don't terminate them with CRLF :-) :-) :-)

                                    Harald Tveit Alvestrand





<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>