ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Lessons Learned from a Foreign Culture

1994-10-27 19:06:55
At 8:54 PM 10/27/94, Mr Rhys Weatherley wrote:
... and NO octets are dropped.  Everything goes through unchanged,
including NULs.

Definitely agree with the NULs.

There is still a question in my mind about what you mean by "unchanged", as
well as what 1521 means by "does not obey SMTP CRLF semantics".

The question is this:

If the content-type requires newline canonicalization, does CTE: binary
override it?  I think it definitely *should* not. I think you could read
the current spec such that it does, though this is not my reading.

The problem datasets are:

1. Normal text with lines, just very long ones.
2. Text that uses CRLF for something other than newline.

I believe that CT: text/plain, CTE: binary is (among other things) for the
former, and that the latter does not belong under type text at all, but
should get a new type.

--
Steve Dorner, Qualcomm Incorporated.  "Oog make mission statement."