My problem is that the semantics of the signature that the mailing
list applies shouldn't depend on whether the original author
happens to be in the same domain as the list.
Of course. That's why list mail should use a different signing
domain. It's clearly a poor idea to sign mail from lists that have
contributors in multiple unknown domains with a d= that has an ADSP
assertion
There still does not seem to be a problem. A DKIM signature allows
source differentiation.
I'm enjoying this whole discussion, and I think it's productive.
Can we draw in the WG participants who haven't yet commented on this?
I'd like to hear your opinions too, and get your ideas on how you'd
like to see this question resolved.
Barry
_______________________________________________
NOTE WELL: This list operates according to
http://mipassoc.org/dkim/ietf-list-rules.html