ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Top Concerns, Issues, Comments

2004-03-20 10:56:49

Some accumulated thoughts

o No Spams this week!  <pondering: something is wrong? checking logs...
nope, all spammers!>

o LMAP works best to protect your own domains.  Low trust in remote domain
checking.

o LMAP has a high DNS overhead for remote domain checking.

o LMAP compliant spammers is a reality!  Can't trust remote checks!

o LMAP only tries to link the DOMAIN and not the USER PART of the email
address.

o CBV continues to prove the return path address is more important than just
the return path domain.

o Anonymous Access Management system *can* work without a fundamental change
to SMTP.

o SMTP functional specifications (the RFCs) must change in order for
technical specification enforcement to take place.

o SMTP functional specifications must change in order for CAN-SPAM can even
begin to work.

o Why is it that I get a constant ~2500 connections? with a constant
spam/rejection 90% rate?

o 80% of all transactions is spoofed.

o Local Domain (HELO) Spoofing is 10%.  80% is RBL rejected, 10% rejected by
CBV

o Many systems don't support extended multi-line response.

o Too many systems rely on "dumb scripting" systems, hence lack of support
for SMTP features.

o SPF needs to get rid of softfail and neutral policies.  If system is not
ready for it, then use it!

Suggestions:

o CAN-SPAM provides two mandates;  return path validation and topic
identication;  Use this model!!

o Add Multiple line greeting to eliminate many of your spammers!  60% on our
system.

o LMAP may provide incentive for the building of "Network Relationships" or
"LMAP-Nets"

o Need SMTP Message-Id Verification (Exist) Feedback System.

o SMTP needs a protocol topic identication command, i.e., "SUBJ"

o BCP: RCPT validation stops SORBIG generation email virus distribution
dependency on bounce mail attacks.

That's it for now.

-- 
Hector Santos, Santronics Software, Inc.
http://www.santronics.com






<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>