ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Can you ever reject mail based on RFC2821 MAIL FROM?

2004-04-24 08:31:53

In <001901c42a04$9bea5d00$6401a8c0(_at_)hdev1> "Hector Santos" 
<hsantos(_at_)santronics(_dot_)com> writes:

20040424 07:43:43 sapspf     : v=spf1 a mx ?all
20040424 07:43:43 sapspf     : neutral (time:6656)

Oh?  a neutral SPF result,  no trust, continue testing.

Ok, you are testing SPF as it was intended and respecting the results.


20040424 07:43:43 sapcep     : test from=testmail.com
20040424 07:43:45 sapcep     : test cdn=hotmail.com
20040424 07:43:46 sapcep     : <ep xmlns='http://ms.net/1'
testing='true'><out><m><indirect>list1._ep.hotmail.com</indirect><indirect>l
ist2._ep.hotmail.com</indirect><indirect>list3._ep.hotmail.com</indirect></m
</out></ep>
20040424 07:43:48 sapcep     : <ep xmlns='http://ms.net/1'
testing='true'><out><m><r>209.240.192.0/19</r><r>65.52.0.0/14</r><r>131.107.
0.0/16</r><r>157.54.0.0/15</r><r>157.56.0.0/14</r><r>157.60.0.0/16</r><r>167
.220.0.0/16</r><r>204.79.135.0/24
20040424 07:43:48 sapcep     : fail (time:4391)

oh look, a CEP test on the from and then CDN returns a reject!?

But, uh, you are testing the C-ID data on the HELO domain instead of
the RFC2822 data as it was designed?  And then not respecting the
"testing='true'" parameter?

Well, if anyone doubted that email receivers will do whatever they
want to, here is proof.


-wayne


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>