One Party Consent Model
2004-07-14 11:49:00
jfcm wrote:
[I separated this response from the others and gave it a new subject,
since I believe it's important]
Hm, you bring up a good point. For example, your asking who are the
endpoints when I send an email to a mailing list, right? I've one
source endpoint, but multiple destination endpoints. So it's not
sufficient if only one of the endpoints authorizes a service.
Now, in case of this example, sending to the mailing list results
basically in multiple transmissions to individuals, in which case
we're back to a scenario with two endpoints.
No. For several reasons.
1. the mailing list the information is sent to is part of the
information. That information cannot be modified without the agreement
of the whole mailing list. If I send a mail to this list saying that you
do not understand this point and I make an OPES to remove you from the list
- I agree so it is OK by your criteria
- you will not respond, so everyone will believe you do not object
- I send another mail agreeing but I make an OPES changing the from
jfc in from markus (I can do it since I am one end). Everyone will
understand that you have agreed not understanding this point
... and you will know nothing of this.
2. Again I am A, you are B and someone is C. An OPES changes B in C. C
will be the receiving end. He has agreed to the change. Is that enough?
May be if B gave authority to C, maybe not if B has not.
See your point, but the example you outline above violates the OPES
tracing requirement, which says that Markus (or B in the generic
example) must be able to trace the OPES service. I.e. I would be aware
of the OPES service that removed me.
Now, I'm not yet sure how to achieve this and whether this is the
full/correct answer...
-Markus
<Prev in Thread] |
Current Thread |
[Next in Thread>
|
- Strawman OPES Charter, Markus Hofmann
- Re: Strawman OPES Charter, Alex Rousskov
- Re: Strawman OPES Charter, jfcm
- One Party Consent Model,
Markus Hofmann <=
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Alex Rousskov
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Markus Hofmann
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Alex Rousskov
- Re: One Party Consent Model, jfcm
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Alex Rousskov
- Re: One Party Consent Model, The Purple Streak, Hilarie Orman
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Markus Hofmann
- Re: One Party Consent Model, The Purple Streak, Hilarie Orman
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Alex Rousskov
- Re: One Party Consent Model, Alex Rousskov
|
|
|