Re: Options for the ID Command

On Tue, 17 May 2005 14:56:56 PDT, David MacQuigg said:

> 1) It provides an unambiguous Identity that we can pick from the SMTP 
> session without transferring the DATA.
> 2) There are no restrictions on the Identity that will favor one method 
> over another. i.e. It's just an Identity that we can check, no additional 
> requirements like it must be the PRA Identity (The reason SUBMITTER is out.)
You *do* realize that you're screwed at this point, because the different 
proposals
check different things.  What should the "identity" be when one proposal wants
"the hostname claimed on the 821 MAIL FROM", another wants "the hostname claimed
on the 822 From:", and another wants the entire left/right side of one or the 
other?

If there was *agreement* on what to check, we'd not have competing proposals.

pgpVlVBKpkdVG.pgp
Description: PGP signature