ietf-smtp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [EAI] Re: I-D Action:draft-hansen-4468upd-mailesc-registry-03.txt

2008-01-22 03:09:57

Tony Hansen wrote:

Internet-Drafts(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org wrote:
A New Internet-Draft is available from the on-line Internet-Drafts
directories.

        Title           : A Registry for SMTP Enhanced Mail System
                          Status Codes
        Author(s)       : T. Hansen, J. Klensin
        Filename        : draft-hansen-4468upd-mailesc-registry-03.txt
Date : 2008-01-10
Ok, so A Registry for SMTP Enhanced Mail System Status Codes,
draft-hansen-4468upd-mailesc-registry, has been updated.

This one represents a proper merger with
draft-klensin-smtp-code-registry, and (I think) addresses almost all of
the comments that have come out since -02.

As requested, it has added a typical Associated Basic Status Code entry
to the registration. It also has a table showing the typical Associated
Basic Status Code for many of the existing codes, seeded with those
found in RFCs 4468 and 4954. There are many holes in this table, though,
that need to be filled in. Please feel free to contribute to this table.

For Isode M-Switch:

  | X.0.0        | any              | X.1.0        | ???              |
  | X.1.1        | ???              | X.1.2        | ???              |

X.1.1 --> 550, 451

  | X.1.3        | ???              | X.1.4        | ???              |
  | X.1.5        | 250              | X.1.6        | ???              |
  | X.1.7        | ???              | X.1.8        | ???              |

X.1.8 --> 501, 451

  | X.2.0        | ???              | X.2.1        | ???              |
  | X.2.2        | 552              | X.2.3        | ???              |
  | X.2.4        | ???              | X.3.0        | ???              |

X.3.0 --> 550, 554, 451

  | X.3.1        | ???              | X.3.2        | ???              |

X.3.1 --> 452

  | X.3.3        | ???              | X.3.4        | 554              |

X.3.4 --> 552 (I think 552 should definitely be allowed in this case)

  | X.3.5        | ???              | X.4.0        | ???              |
  | X.4.1        | 451              | X.4.2        | ???              |
  | X.4.3        | ???              | X.4.4        | ???              |

X.4.3 --> 451, 550

  | X.4.5        | ???              | X.4.6        | ???              |
  | X.4.7        | ???              | X.5.0        | 250, 554, 503    |

X.5.0 --> 250, 503, 451, 452

  | X.5.1        | ???              | X.5.2        | ???              |

X.5.1 --> 501, 503, 530, 550, 554, 555, 430
X.5.2 --> 500, 501, 502, 555

  | X.5.3        | ???              | X.5.4        | ???              |

X.5.4 --> 501, 451, 555

  | X.5.5        | ???              | X.5.6        | 500              |
  | X.6.0        | ???              | X.6.1        | ???              |
  | X.6.2        | ???              | X.6.3        | 554              |
  | X.6.4        | 250              | X.6.5        | ???              |
  | X.6.6        | 554              | X.7.0        | 235, 454, 530,   |

X.6.6 --> 554

  |              |                  |              | 554              |

X.7.0 --> 504, 535, 454, 220

  | X.7.1        | 550              | X.7.2        | ???              |

X.7.1 --> 550, 551, 451

X.7.2 --> 550

  | X.7.3        | ???              | X.7.4        | ???              |
  | X.7.5        | ???              | X.7.6        | ???              |
  | X.7.7        | ???              | X.7.8        | 554, 535         |
  | X.7.9        | 534              | X.7.11       | 538              |
  | X.7.12       | 432              |              |                  |