ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [Hist Trivia] IP Protocol Layers

2001-07-18 02:00:02
By 1983 the Internet protocols were already being recast in OSI terms.

I think it started before that. In September 1982 Padlipsky wrote RFC 
871, reacting to the increasing perception that ISO had somehow invented 
the concept of layering:

   Despite the fact that "the ARPANET" stands as the
 proof-of-concept of intercomputer networking and, as discussed in
 more detail below, introduced such fundamental notions as
 Layering and Virtualizing to the literature, the wide
 availability of material which appeals to the International
 Standards Organization's Reference Model for Open System
 Interconnection (ISORM) has prompted many new- comers to the
 field to overlook the fact that, even though it was largely
 tacit, the designers of the ARPANET protocol suite have had a
 reference model of their own all the long.  That is, since well
 before ISO even took an interest in "networking", workers in the
 ARPA-sponsored research community have been going about their
 business of doing research and development in intercomputer
 networking with a particular frame of reference in mind.  They
 have, unfortunately, either been so busy with their work or were
 perhaps somehow unsuited temperamentally to do learned papers on
 abstract topics when there are interesting things to be said on
 specific topics, that it is only in very recent times that there
 has been much awareness in the research community of the impact
 of the ISORM on the lay mind.  When the author is asked to review
 solemn memoranda comparing such things as the ARPANET treatment
 of "internetting" with that of CCITT employing the ISORM "as the
 frame of reference," however, the time has clearly come to
 attempt to enunciate the ARPANET Reference Model (ARM)
 publicly--for such comparisons are painfully close to comparing
 an orange with an apple using redness and smoothness as the
 dominant criteria, given the philosophical closeness of the CCITT
 and ISO models and their mutual disparities from the ARPANET
 model.

Stuart Cheshire <cheshire(_at_)apple(_dot_)com>
 * Wizard Without Portfolio, Apple Computer
 * Chairman, IETF ZEROCONF
 * www.stuartcheshire.org