ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Last Call: Using SOAP in BEEP to Proposed Standard

2001-09-11 18:10:03
Putting the Web Services world in a situation where it needs a discovery 
protocol
to find out how to layer SOAP is not at all an abstract issue. Or do you think
the WSDL for each Web Service is going to define the available layerings? What
is a poor vendor to do other than support all of them, and what is the 
technical
justification for that? imho this is an absolutely valid last call issue.
(If this had been a WG work item, it would have been discussed as a WG charter
issue.)

I don't have an opinion on the larger issue here, but I did want to
point out that the "Web Services world" is far from clear about what
it wants to achieve, let alone *how*.  There exists major architectural
disconnects between existing Web architecture, and the architecture
commonly associated to "Web Services".

IMO, it's premature to use that as an example.

MB



<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>