ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Last Call: IETF and ITU-T Collaboration Guidelines to Informational

2002-03-05 11:30:03

3.2.2 ITU-T recognition at ISOC/IETF

   ITU-T Study Group Chairmen can authorize one or more members to
   attend an IETF meeting as an official ITU-T delegate speaking
   authoritatively on behalf of the Study Group (or a particular
   Rapporteur Group). 

This seems rather at odds with the tradition that IETF participants are
individuals who represent their own technical judgement rather than 
that of some other organization.  

I think it needs to be explicitly said that the opinions stated by
such representatives are for information of the WG only and are not 
considered in determining WG consensus.  The last thing we need is
to have delegates from other organizations given more consideration 
in IETF WGs than the technical judgement of individual IETF participants.

Keith