ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: Last Call: CR-LDP Extensions for ASON to Informational

2003-01-23 15:51:40
Hi,

I just saw the message that this document has been approved.  I
have a question about the process.

Definition in RFC 2434, "IETF Consensus - New values are assigned through
the IETF consensus process".  The CR-LDP code points are clearly marked
as "IETF Consensus", not IESG Approval.

I have heard repeatedly, from at least 5 different ADs that three people
for and one against does *not* constitute a consensus -- in fact, this
was repeated in the TE WG list a couple of days ago.

There were several people that raised various objections, from nits
to technical issues.  Many remain unanswered.

Am I to understand that the IESG inferred consensus from the discussions
that have taken place (and are still under way)?

Kireeti.




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>