ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Last Call: IP over MIME to Proposed Standard

2003-05-24 06:20:38
    > From: Keith Moore <moore(_at_)cs(_dot_)utk(_dot_)edu>

    >> IP over foo is not exactly packet science, that's why.

    > nor is it standards-track material.

Anything that more than two "real user" entities are going to want to use,
and *might want to inter-operate*, is probably standards-track material.

About the only reason not to do it would be if it was decided that the
design chosen was technologically flawed. However, I think NAT should have
taught the IETF (as bridges taught me) that sometimes what seems
technologically flawed is in fact just what the market needs and wants -
usually for some reason one hasn't sufficiently appreciated.

So I would generally err very much on the side of caution, and stay with the
standard in the first paragraph. (Even if it does sound like an April 1
escapee...)

        Noel