ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: myth of the great transition (was US Defense Department forma lly adopts IPv6)

2003-06-18 22:21:39
Valdis,

Valdis Kletnieks wrote:
If it doesn't work through a firewall, it's because the
firewall is doing what you ASKED it to do - block certain
classes of connections.

I'm sorry but it is nothing near being that simple. Although if it does
not work through a firewall, it MAYBE because the firewall does block a
class of traffic (more likely because someone forgot to punch the right
hole), there are _plenty_ of other reasons why it does not work through
a firewall, one of the top ones being asymmetric traffic when there is
more than one exit point and the firewall hard state not being
distributed.
 
Melinda Shore <mshore(_at_)cisco(_dot_)com> writes:
None of these things worked real well through firewalls
either, which is sort of my point.

Melinda's point is perfectly valid. To quote Brian Carpenter, state is
evil and distributed state is worse.
Unfortunately, they are part of the network engineer's life.

Michel.




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>