[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Thoughts on the nomcom process

2008-03-16 13:07:11

Spencer Dawkins wrote:
You did something very GOOD this time - you invoked the never-before-invoked 
arbitration process, instead of secretly resolving an "irresistable force 
meets immovable object" dispute. Please accept credit for this good 
judgement, especially if you are assigning blame to yourself.


Dispute does not have to mean nastiness; for any interesting human 
collaboration, some dispute is inevitable.

Everything I have heard about how this resolution process went indicates that 
was handled diligently and constructively.  Independent of one's opinion of 
Scott's decision, it is clear that this matter got serious and deep thought, 
with real concern for longer-term implications.

That's as much as anyone can reasonably ask for.



   Dave Crocker
   Brandenburg InternetWorking
IETF mailing list