At 20.13 +0100 04-02-01, Iljitsch van Beijnum wrote:
Simple: not all computers support non-latin scripts. If
I'm going to administer a mail system I must be able to
set up filters and such which makes it necessary to have
support for the scripts that I may need to filter.
If we allow non-latin characters in e-mail addresses,
we should put into the standard that all e-mail addresses
which contain non-latin characters MUST also contain
a version of the same e-mail address which is in only
latin characters (just like the business card with
address in English on one page and in the local language
on the other side). This means that in every transmission
or display of such e-mail addresses, the non-latin
version must be accompanied by a latin version.
Note that this solution will not cause additional
complexity for users, since people can always choose to use
only the Latin version of an e-mail address, also when they
send mail to someone having a dual address. Only those who
want to use the non-Latin address will have to use the dual
address. And this will in practice mostly be e-mail
addresses taking from previous incoming messages, or from
address books.
If we do this, we can allow non-Latin characters in
e-mail addresses without the problems you indicate.
--
Jacob Palme <jpalme(_at_)dsv(_dot_)su(_dot_)se> (Stockholm University and KTH)
for more info see URL: http://www.dsv.su.se/jpalme/