spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: softfail considered harmful

2004-02-18 09:19:58
On Wednesday 18 February 2004 14:23, David Brodbeck wrote:
By your definition, postal mail is unreliable and nothing more than a
"toy", too.  Lots of people throw out advertising flyers and other junk
mail without reading it.

Not a good analogy since these people are reading the mail, to the extent 
required to determine if they wish to read further.

Most people would not be happy if the postman tried unreliably to 'guess' what 
was (in his opinion) junk and throw it away before it reaches you. 

They would probably be a little happier if the postman tried unreliably to 
'guess' what was (in his opinion) junk and automatically returned it to the 
sender as undeliverable mail. Or even better, if the sender was prevented 
from sending it in the first place. Particularly if the criteria were 
objective and non-descriminatory rules for sender authentication.

At least this way no mail is just 'mysteriously disappeared'.


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>