xsl-list
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: killing xslt

2004-05-13 08:28:38


I think the real reason Microsoft aren't 
investing in XSLT is that they
aren't making any money out of it, which 
is because they can't compete with
free software. There are plenty of XSLT 
enthusiasts inside the company, as
the blog indicates, but they don't have 
any funding. 
Well this was one of the things that I saw 
as the reason for the complexity of the new 
wd, if it becomes complex enough you weed 
out the competition. 


The sad part of this is that it pretty 
well kills XSLT on the browser, which
always held out so much promise if only 
the interoperability problems could
be sorted out. 
I don't know if it kills XSLT on the 
browser. There is I assume still quite a 
long time before MS will release any browser 
that is .net based.


XQuery in its current form is no good at 
document transformation, and even
for data, it's got much less functionality 
than XSLT 2.0. It will succeed as
a database query language, which is what 
it's designed for, but I don't
think it will ever threaten the space 
where XSLT is currently used.
I don't know, success of a language is often 
tied to developer intuition of its future 
viability, lack of Windows support makes for 
an argument against such viability for some 
people. It's a hit, not a knockout. hmm, 
maybe it's only a slap, but I feel hurt. 
:(




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>