ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

re: binary transport vs 8bit character transport revisited (was: why it is a problem to transmit binary as binary in mail)

1991-09-13 23:20:30
Although John's comments are correct in so far as they go, it should be clear
that John and I do represent different camps.

For the record, I'm against 8-bit character oriented transport too, on the
grounds that:
 . it is going to be a lot of work to get things interoperable with extant
   7-bit software
 . it is West-Euro-centric
 . it does not solve the general problem of international character sets
 . it merely includes Western Europeans in the privileged class of those who
   don't have to worry about the problem of international characters.

The first reason is the technical reason; the others are moral reasons.

Unlike some, I see nothing magic in 8-bit datums as opposed to 7-bit, 36-bit,
9-bit, 14-bit, 15-bit, etc.  I don't think the limited benefits of 8-bit
transport are worth the cost.