Hector, I like your table, but I hope you are viewing this as input
into the working group rather than as a precondition for creating the
working group. And to be clear, I'm fine with including advice to
deployers about how to react in the scope of the WG.
Like several others here, I'm concerned that we're being nudged
toward doing an unusual amount of work before chartering. The most
obvious of this is the Threat Analysis, which seems to be a moving
target with no sign that it is going to stabilize in my lifetime. If
we're also being told that we have to specify the verifier behavior
as a precondition for chartering then I suspect that we'll end up
being told to essentially write all the documents before we're
allowed to charter. Which is I guess one way to make it both the
shortest and the longest WG on record simultaneously.
eric
_______________________________________________
ietf-dkim mailing list
http://dkim.org