ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: suggested new RRtype experiment

2004-05-21 15:56:45

On Fri, 2004-05-21 at 14:01, Bob Atkinson wrote:
Compile time in the sense that contents of the .xsd schema are fixed as
part of the specification.

The particular techniques for connecting to the .xsd via the namespace
are carried out per the XML Schema specification.

Are you insisting this http reference remain?

If this schema is fixed as part of the specifications, then adding any
reference other than the registered version (document type) is not
needed nor desired.  This http link is offering a mechanism for ad hoc
modifications or extensions.  It is not, by any means, for the
programmer's convenience.

It is not a desired feature for a widely deployed rudimentary function. 
This template already comprises more that twice the data possibly
contained in the DNS record.  Leaving in a mechanism to allow such
definitions to change at the publishers discretion is perilous.

-Doug