ietf-smtp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Response to appeal from John Klensin dated 13-Jun-2008

2008-07-08 04:42:20


On Jul 8, 2008, at 6:19 AM, SM wrote:


Hi Tony,
At 15:35 07-07-2008, Tony Hansen wrote:
Quick poll:

John has said to me that he's always been willing to change the non- example domain names to 2606 example domain names.

Now that the appeal is done and out of the way, do people prefer

1) none of the domain names be changed?
2) all domain names be changed, except Jon Postel's isi.edu and usc.edu references
3) all domain names be changed

I prefer (1) as such changes may entail more than simply adding .example at the end of the domain names.

+1, both for that pragmatic reason and the issues raised by Ned and Dave, amongst others.

Cheers,
  Steve