ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: recommendation against publication of draft-cerpa-necp-02.txt

2000-04-10 09:00:03
Bottom line is that IP-layer interception - even when done "right" - 
has fairly limited applicability for location of nearby content.
Though the technique is so widely mis-applied that it might still be 
useful to define what "right" means.

And there you have the argument for publishing this document.  I much prefer a
model where we allow for free exchange of ideas, even bad ones.  I tend to
believe that if someone took the time to write up a document that there's
probably some reason for it.  So let's call this an experimental RFC and get
on with life.  Isn't that what the experimental category denotes?

Derrell