ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: My point about the ambiguity of the question

2003-05-02 12:17:59
Keith Moore wrote:
Ambiguity is one of the issues associated with site local, 
not the only one. 
...
As the second note shows, part of the goal of some
votes is to disallow a network manager the ability to limit 
access or 
visibility to some of their nodes.

As the author of the second note, I can authoritatively say 
that this is a misinterpretation. 

So please explain how I misinterpreted. Everything that is not about
ambiguity is about the simple ability to consistently limit access or
visibility, and identify when that is being done. 

We don't need to deprecate SL to fix the ambiguity, so the insistence
that deprecating SL fixes other things only leads to the conclusion that
this is about limiting a network manager's ability to define how his
network is run. That is not the IETF's call, so those votes are not
valid.

Tony