Additional input for your consideration.
Margaret(_dot_)Wasserman(_at_)nokia(_dot_)com wrote:
...
In other words, we found that there was consensus to deprecate AND
replace site-locals, ...
Witness the situation where the chair is after the fact defining what the
working group agreed to. There was nothing about 'replacement' in the
question that was asked.
Coupling this with her earlier comment:
I think it should be harder to add a new feature to a specification
than to take one out.
shows that, now as AD, the bar for a disambiguated local range will be
higher if the pronouncement is allowed to stand, than what is necessary to
fix the existing specification.
Tony