Thanks for the list; the cut-off point is probably somewhat
subjective, but I see at least several protocols on the list that one
can consider reasonably successful, as in having several well-known
implementations, shipping as part of common desktop or server
operating systems, references by other standards-bodies and/or large-
scale operational deployments:
Enum
XMPP
SCTP
IPSec
MPLS
CalDav
RTP
IMAP4
PPP
LDAP
GEOPRIV (right now, mostly through the LLDP-MED effort, rather than
directly)
Diameter (3G)
iSCSI
SIEVE
I'm probably missing some due to unfamiliarity. This doesn't seem like
such a bad batting average.
MSRP isn't really finished yet, so that's probably a bit premature to
judge.
On Dec 31, 2007, at 3:47 PM, Dave Crocker wrote:
IPv6
DNSSec
Enum
XMPP
CPIM
BEEP
MSRP
SCTP
IPSec
SASL
MPLS
CalDav
RTP
NETCONF
IMAP4
PPP
(a variety of PKI efforts?)
LDAP
OPES
VPIM
FFPIM
GEOPRIV
Diameter
iSCSI
DDDS
SIEVE
A number of questions come to mind:
1. What additions or removals should be made to the list?
2. Has the protocol (or set of protocols that pertain to the
acronym) gained widespread adoption and if so, what does
"widespread" mean and what does "adoption" mean? Having 100M+ daily
users is definitive, but what about smaller numbers that nonetheless
dominate an important niche, such as "LAN-email office workers"?
3. ...?
d/
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf