procmail
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: GNU sed version 2.05 is broken?

1997-10-23 00:50:25
On Wed, 22 Oct 1997 you (Philip Guenther) wrote:
There is only one GNU sed 2.05.  You have the Redhat RPM sed-2.05-6,
which besides containing GNU sed 2.05, includes a manpage that is
incorrect.  The documentation is in error, not the program.

My dupe filter was switched off when I got this, and I replied to Philip  
without replying to the group.

Just to lay this to rest:

I was wrong to say there were "several versions" of sed 2.05.  I should  
have said "several distributions".

At least one of these distributions tries to make up for the lack of a  
man page (I never did understand GNUs aversion to man pages) by including  
a man page provided by Eric S. Raymond <esr(_at_)snark(_dot_)thyrsus(_dot_)com>.

This man page attributes to the GNU binary a -g option that certainly  
appears in earlier seds but which seems to have been dropped without  
comment by GNU.

I would suggest that you a) report this as a bug to RedHat; and b) edit
or remove the manpage.

Done and done.


el bid

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>