spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: SPF will solve spam and punish spammers

2004-07-24 09:04:07
On Sat, 24 Jul 2004 10:52:45 -0400, John Keown wrote
I agree thousand are running secure and compliant servers but 
millions are not adhering to the standards. Just look at the list of 
known open relays mail servers on the net in any major blacklist. 
These have been used by spammers and yet they are still open relays.

And a fair number of open relays are run by large companies, historically.

Raising the cost of owning a domain will not solve the spam problem, and it 
will accellerate the transformation of the Internet from a place where ideas 
can be interchanged freely to a corporate-run, broadcast-only medium like 
radio or television.

Your certification schemes also imply some kind of central authority.  Who 
would run this?  How would you ensure it acted fairly and didn't become 
corrupt or captured by the direct marketing industry?  The history of 
centralized government media regulation is not an encouraging one.