spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

nullMX, VARA, op=trusted, (was: This is ridiculous.)

2005-06-09 09:32:49
wayne wrote:

Could you imagine the screaming by the root servers if this
idea was wildly used without *all* software that deals with
MX records not recognizing that "." means "don't try to send
email".

I just tested `nslookup .` watching my modem LEDs - *SCREAM*
Now that is really stupid.  I still hope that the first DNS
server did the right thing without bothering the root servers.

What a truly bad idea.

It's a hack, like using TLD .invalid where some syntax insists
on <addr-spec>.  For Bruce's clean From-optional idea we need
your time-machine - or is it limited to 2003 ?  <g>  Bye, Frank

P.S.:  I just got a PM with an improved "forwardmaster plan",
as far as I can tell it this should work to bypass SPF (per
user) where necessary:  <http://wiki.outboundindex.net/VarA>

Maybe add this link to the new SPF site...  I guess there are
now enough better ideas than the old op=trusted, so I'll kill
the latter from the next draft-spf-6-3-options unless somebody
cries "no".



<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>