ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: A spec for showing language in MIME headers

1993-11-11 12:33:23
    Am I missing the point?

slightly, the advent of speach-interactive hardware is obliging 
some of us to deal with the concept of new ways to "read" 
text.

The blind are a significant population, many more of them 
would be enabled to use computers given suitable "readers", 
and vocal rendition of arbitrary text is beginning to rear 
its ugly head in the real world.

    With text, the purpose (as I understand it) of the
  various headers is to convey to the user agent the
  information necessary to choose the correct character
  set and language conventions for displaying the
  message.

Yes, unfortunatly "display" is not necessarily limited to 
the visual forms we have come to love/hate.

  Language variants that have no impact on the textual
  display, I believe, therefore do not need to be
  represented in the MIME headers for text delivery.

unfortunatly, this all hinges on the meaning of "display".

    For voice messages carried by MIME, I believe that
  language specification has no effect on the message
  delivery and is therefore relevant only to the
  recipient(s) of a message, in giving them a clue 
  of what to expect.

Assuming that the format of the voice message incorporates 
the dialect (ie, digitized sound) this would be true, 
provided no alternative text or sign rendering technology 
is conceivable.
--
dana s emery <de19(_at_)Umail(_dot_)umd(_dot_)edu>