ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Internationalization of the Internet

1994-11-20 14:23:30
Masatka Ohta writes:

So, the current MIME specification for non-Mime mail that says:

            Default RFC 822 messages are typed by this protocol as plain
            text  in the US-ASCII character set, which can be explicitly
            specified as "Content-type:  text/plain;  charset=us-ascii".

should be removed, because, for you, it is specification on non-MIME
mails and, for me, it is obstacle to the Internationalized Internet.

I think this shows a fundamental misunderstanding.  That paragraph
simply RESTATES, in terms of the MIME content-type, the definition that
was already made in RFC 822.  RFC 822 makes it very clear that messages
are 7-bit ASCII.  All that this paragraph does is to explain how that
pre-existent reality is expressed in MIME terms.  

The fact that various local communities sent things other than ASCII
around in pre-MIME mail is important, but not relevant to the
standardization issue:  Those uses were clearly out of spec with regard
to RFC 822, and were an important reason why MIME was designed in the
first place!  -- Nathaniel