ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: Proposed IESG Statement on the Conclusion of Experiments

2012-04-20 08:37:30
What about the idea of requiring new Experimental documents to include text 
that indicates when the experiment is to be considered completed absent new 
work on it?  Essentially, the document declares a date by which the experiment 
is considered concluded, and code points automatically deprecated, and the 
document itself goes to Historic status, unless some other document action 
updates the deadline or moves the work to the Standards Track.

Keeping track of such dates to trigger these actions by default becomes a new 
burden for the Secretariat, I imagine.  I don't know what that cost would be 
compared to the "cost" of experiments currently languishing in this unresolved 
state.

To Eliot's point, work that is resumed much later could always restore document 
and code point status and declare new drop-dead dates when it becomes 
interesting again.

-MSK


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>