ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [Recentattendees] IETF 100, Singapore -- proposed path forward and request for input

2016-05-17 14:19:37
On 5/17/16 13:14, IAOC Chair wrote:
The IAOC meetings committee reviewed the options for IETF 100, including 
investigating costs and possibilities of moving the meeting to a different 
location.  In keeping with the updated process outlined below, they checked 
with official advisory sources and consulted with specialty travel services, 
frequent travelers, and local representatives about the concerns that have been 
raised.  The input received from those sources is consistent with the text on 
http://travel.state.gov [1].

 From that research, at a strictly practical level, the IAOC believes that it 
is possible to have a successful meeting in Singapore.  The IAOC proposes that 
holding the meeting in Singapore is the best option for IETF 100 at this time.

Next Step:

The IAOC would like to hear from the community by June 1st, 2016 on barriers to 
holding a successful meeting in Singapore. Responses should be directed to 
venue-selection(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org


I have a hard time making a valid evaluation of this topic. I suspect many people who will weigh in over the next few weeks are in a similar situation, even if they don't realize it. I include the IAOC in this characterization.

It is very difficult to interpret the effect of potentially oppressive environments on the potentially oppressed if you are not a member of that group. It would be presumptuous for a majority straight population to make this decision on behalf of those people actually impacted.

So I'm going to withhold expressing support for or opposition to the proposed course of action until we hear from GLBTQ IETFers in light of the information the IAOC is offering as rationale for continuing to pursue Singapore as a venue.

But to be clear: I will almost certainly forgo attending a meeting at which any of my GLBTQ colleagues felt unwelcome. I would actively encourage others to adopt the same stance. Whether this forms a barrier to a successful meeting is up for debate; however, It would almost certainly be a setback for the working groups I chair.

/a