spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Re: SPF is not usable as legal measure against spammers.

2004-07-20 14:11:38
Len Conrad wrote:


It should not be mandatory for a PTR record to match "the" A record.


it should be mandatory that the PTR and A match

But any reliable publisher of PTR records should publish at least an A record that matches it


contradicting your above

, even if it's not "the" A record.


WTF??



The owner of the address block needs to publish only one PTR record -- it needs to resolve to only one name (obviously), which should be in a domain also owned by the owner of the address block.

Client domains may, of course, publish A records. There is, of course, no way of guaranteeing there is a PTR record that will match that name -- only that some PTR record exists.