spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: draft of email security glossary for review

2004-12-28 10:54:57

On Tue, 28 Dec 2004, Alex van den Bogaerdt wrote:

  DNS domains are in fact groups of HOST records and DOMAIN is something
  that has been delegated within DNS hierarchy (i.e. its what is pointed 

Again: I think you are confusing zones, domains and other related
stuff.  If you are going to present it as a fact sheet, make sure
you get it right.

You are describing a ZONE and are calling it a domain. That in
itself is not wrong, because a zone _is_ a domain.  However, it
is not true that a domain must be a group of hosts.

A zone can consist of records for multiple domains so they are not same 
thing! It is true however that zones are distinguished by being at 
different dns authority levels.

Domain seems rather flexible term as many use it however what I described 
is the most common understanding that sigle host that is defined only 
within a zome is not necessarily a domain (although it will become one
if it has attributes other then just "A") or has a sub-heircarchy with
other hosts. 

But we seem to be getting too much into dns detail nitpicking (rather 
then email related matters which is what this glossary is about), so I 
have specific question if the following description which is currently 
in the glossary is correct or not:

DOMAIN: 
  Domain Name (or just Domain) is a very common term for internet 
infrastructure that refers to naming of all internet end-points which have 
names like c.b.a, i.e. its long name separate by number of ".". The naming 
system is hierarchical and ICANN is de-jure (but not necessarily de-facto 
for every internet user) authority to decide on the list of "a" or root 
TLDs. Name delegation in each TLD is done by different Registrars and in 
the end each ISP (or directly end-user) has been delegated one or more 
Domains which the user either uses directly as FQDN or sets up HOSTS for 
each system.

-- 
William Leibzon
Elan Networks
william(_at_)elan(_dot_)net