spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: For SPF Council review - PASS Definition - was: People keep misunderstanding what "Pass" and "Neutral" mean

2005-05-19 17:41:38
Scott Kitterman wrote:

 SOFTFAIL   <<no idea on this one>>
Probably forged, but I'm not sure.  Approach with caution and if you get one
of these, I wouldn't mind hearing about it as there may be one of my users
out there doing something I didn't now about.

Yeah, I started sending 417's on this one and found that too many postings from legitimate email lists were getting caught in it. So I've fallen back on just kicking the FAILs and letting the SOFTFAILs go through.

 FAIL       Shred it now... don't open it.
 PASS       We'll vouch for it, but follow best practices anyway.
TempError      Hold off and try again in a little while, something is broken
PermError      Something is broken and it won't get better.  You ought to
wonder about this one.

But are TempError and PermError SPF results, or are you instead referring to 4xx and 5xx SMTP results?

Just my interpretation.  The spec is still the best reading:


yeah, it is very interesting. Wound up finding a reference to it after my original post.


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>