In <200505201913(_dot_)57155(_dot_)bulk(_at_)mehnle(_dot_)net> Julian Mehnle
<bulk(_at_)mehnle(_dot_)net> writes:
Wayne Schlitt wrote:
Julian Mehnle writes:
"redirect=" should always work as if the SPF check started over. This
follows from the principle of least surprise, i.e. it is what the user
expects.
Ok, so say example.com has a redirect to nxdomain.example.org. I
think getting a "None" result from checking example.com when
there clearly is an SPF record there will be quite surprising to
people also.
_I_ am not the one saying that SPF(non-existent-domain) should result in
"None".
Ok, fine, change that to redirecting to
host-exists-but-no-spf-record.example.org.
But as a matter of principle, "redirect=" should always work as if the SPF
check started over. IMO, this is what the user expects.
Ok. I still think it is confusing to have example.org having an SPF
record, but when evaluated, it results in "None".
-wayne