-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Frank Ellermann wrote:
Julian Mehnle wrote:
It seems we lost track of the many council review requests,
which indeed have reached a somewhat inflationary use.
.......................................^^^^^^^^^^^^
IIRC 4 from you, 3 from Scott, 2 from me, 1 from Mark.
Alright. I can only remember 3 review requests of mine.
As for the SPF(non-existent-domain) == PermError thing, I already sort of
admitted that bringing it up was a mistake, but I'll happily admit it
again.
The domain label 63 characters limit warning for section 9.3.1.2 no one
really seemed to understand, so I forced the issue.
The s/prefix/$SEMANTICALLY_DESCRIPTIVE_NAME/ thing was obviously quite
controversial, so it appeared there was no way we would be deciding it by
argument.
What was the 4th one?
The RfC 2828 issue was no formal review request, I mentioned
it anyway in the new thread "pointers for the Council / Wayne"
New thread as wanted by you. And sure like hell the Council
discussed "authorize" vs. "authenticate" without RfC 2828 :-(
It is still not clear to me what larger context you are alluding to.
*I* do know what the difference between "authentication" and "authoriza-
tion" is. Apparently, some of us think that the concept of "authentica-
tion" should be strictly kept out of the SPF specification, and although I
can understand their reasoning, I don't agree with it. However, talking
about references to RFC 2828 is of little use as long as we haven't agreed
that the concept of "authentication" should be a part of the spec in the
first place. So, as I said, I'm not sure what you are complaining about
here.
If at all possible, we really should decide things by
argument, not by voting.
Yes, please make this possible. Pure fun like a "sign" vote not
withstanding.
The s/prefix/.../ issue may be of minor importance, but it certainly wasn't
brought up for fun. :-)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQFCl7cywL7PKlBZWjsRAukSAJ4ihQ5zV3YLlAJqqYQuVBmmAH3r1gCgxtso
dTAhIhIcePBawoa8NUfeNTA=
=ghoC
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----