spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Re: When does the record end?

2005-07-20 16:07:23
| However, in all cases, any syntax errors anywhere in the
| record MUST be detected.


Whatever you do, if you got no match before the "moo" you MUST
report a PermError.  You cannot ignore or skip "moo" if you're
at it.

The paragraph before this also says, "If there are any syntax errors, check_host() returns immediately with the result 'PermError'."

Since it doesn't say something more like "If any syntax errors were found..." which would give some leniency toward whether or not I happened to get far enough to encounter them, I interpreted it to say that I do have to go through the entire v=spf1 record at least doing some basic parsing.

Currently, my implementation goes left-to-right, but if it's already found a match, then it only looks at the syntax of the remaining tokens. Upon finding "moo" at the end, it changes the final result to PermError.

--Marc