ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: I-D Recommendations for Automatic Responses to Electronic Mail

2002-06-06 10:42:19

I wouldn't have put in auto-submitted except that some uniform means
of marking automatic responses is necessary to prevent loops.  There
are heuristics that could be used instead, but they don't work as well.

Using a MAIL FROM of <> for autoresponses meets the requirement to
prevent loops.  Auto-submitted is only useful (to meet the 'prevent
loops' requirement) when the MAIL FROM isn't null.  For other reasons
there is some additional value in including auto-submitted even if
MAIL FROM is <>.

one reason I didn't just insist that MAIL FROM be <>  is that too
many mailers categorically reject MAIL FROM:<>.  yes, they're broken,
but there's so much of this kind of brokenness in the world that a 
feature that depends on it not being broken is doomed to failure...

there are also things that rewrite <> to MAILER-DAEMON or some such,
presumably because mailers don't accept <>.

Keith

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>