ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: So here it is one year later...

2005-01-30 02:57:22

Alan DeKok wrote:

The consensus was to look at 2822 and Sender-Id.

That was a decree and no consensus.  CSV was declared off topic
until the 2822 discussions were ready, and as a result CSV was
never discussed.  Same problem for classic SPF, minus the one
week when the former WG chair asked for a spf2.0/mfrom draft,
and let the WG be closed three (?) days after it was published.

There's a serious problem with RfC 3710 (4.3) vs. RfC 2418 (4).
It's a bad sign that 3710 and 2418 are now among the relatively
few RfCs that I know, thanks but no thanks to MARID. :-(

                      Bye, Frank