ietf-openpgp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: "Yes, I can handle PGP/MIME"

2004-04-16 03:22:38

On Fri, 16 Apr 2004, Will Price wrote:

In the absence of a definitive non-advisory flag, we solved this
problem over a year ago, and the solution is now deployed in many
versions of shipping products. Since PGP products never (before PGP

For the record, I believe this "solution" to be ill-advised. Implementing
such hacks without discussion in this group will result in continued
compatibility issues between OpenPGP implementations.

I informed the product manager of PGP Universal of this error before the
product originally shipped, but was told it was too late to change tactics
at that point. Nevertheless, I still believe that the "preferred
keyserver" packet should indicate preferred keyservers, and that
MIME-encoding preferences should be indicated elsewhere.

Your solution is a hack, and an unnecessary one, since there is an elegant
means of expressing such information already built into OpenPGP -- the
notation data packet. I hope this is corrected in future releases of PGP
Universal.



--Len.


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>