[Top] [All Lists]

Re: draft-kucherawy-greylisting-bcp

2011-10-26 12:05:29

One 'interesting' aspect of an interop test for greylisting is that it would 
only affect servers.  Greylisting is supposed to be backward compatible with 
standards-conforming clients.   What you would want to establish via 
interoperability testing is that a server that implements greylisting per the 
RFC doesn't degrade interoperability with existing, properly-implemented, 

I don't have a strong opinion of BCP vs. standards-track for this.  I think 
that if it's desirable to publish an RFC on this topic (which I doubt), either 
BCP or PS would suffice.   But I do think that if it's going to be published as 
PS, the document needs to define testing criteria for advancement.