I tend to feel that both the decisions of the IAD and of the IAOC
should be appealable.
My thinking tends toward thinking that anyone should be able to appeal
the decision, or any practice including the accounting practices, of
the IAD. I believe we are defining high standards of transparency, as
I think we should, but transparency without recourse can be
problematic.
I think anyone, or perhaps any group of people, should be able to
appeal IAD actions to the IAOC.
the chain of appeal could be either:
a. the normal iaoc-iesg-iab-isoc bot
b. iaoc - a joint iab/iesg appeals committee (that excluded iaoc
members) set up to hear the appeal - isoc bot
c. an abbreviated chain iaoc-isoc bot
As for the IAOC, I believe their actions should be appealable as well
and should use the same chain as an IAD appeal.
a.
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf