ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Moderation on ietf(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org

2014-07-22 12:07:46
At 12:16 PM 7/22/2014, IETF Chair wrote:

This message proposes a problem exists and then without any discussion
announces a decision.

I want to clarify what the mail said. It said we are planning to do this and 
called for feedback. A decision will be made after discussion.

Jari


Hi Jari  -

"Planning to do this" implies "we've already decided and it will go forward 
unless something changes.  

Perhaps instead - "We're considering approaches to manage noise on the IETF 
list.  One possibility discussed by the IESG is providing moderators to 
remonstrate with the noise producers prior to action by the sergeant-at-arms.  
The IESG would like to solicit comments on this and also solicit guidance on 
other possibilities prior to making any decision".

Thanks - Mike