[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [Asrg] Adding a spam button to MUAs

2010-01-27 20:46:23
On 1/27/10 7:40 AM, Steve Atkins wrote:
On Jan 27, 2010, at 4:47 AM, Rich Kulawiec wrote:
  there is no way that any end-user should
ever be permitted to classify anything as spam/not-spam. [1]
Given that pretty much all operational definitions of "spam" are based
on whether the email was unsolicited or unwanted, and the recipient is
typically the only person who is likely to be able to tell whether a particular
piece of email is something they wanted or asked to receive, I'm
pretty sure you've got that wrong.
1) End-users are not always able to determine where an email originated. Even with Authentication-Results included, this header omits the source IP address of the message, leaving the actual source uncertain. So who is to blame?

2) Not all unwanted email falls into a definition of spam. Unfortunately, when provided a limited set of options, pressing a "This is Spam" button likely communicates a message as unwanted or is considered junk, even when from a mailing-list previously opted in, or perhaps an auto-response in language the end-user is unable to read. After all, not all recipients share a common native language.

End-users can be a poor judge as to what is spam. Abuse desks receiving complaints of unwanted email need to ascertain whether there is evidence of spam, such as content clearly in the commercial interest of the sender, and not the recipient, etc.


Asrg mailing list