ietf-mailsig
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Better DKIM Verification Example Needed

2005-07-28 07:43:15

Earl Hood wrote:
On July 27, 2005 at 15:26, Michael Thomas wrote:


IMO, it is much cleaner to have the signature in its own header
field so header field canonicalization is uniform across all
fields.


What happens if you have more than one signature? I don't see it as
any cleaner and in fact it looks like it adds complexity to me.


I'm assuming the complexity is associating the signature data
with the meta-info data.  If the header fields are the same
name, their proximity together determines what goes with what.
I believe Ned stated in the past that re-arranging of same-named
header fields does not happen, or is extremely rare.

I don't understand what is to be gained, and I see a lot of
extra processing, complexity, and chances for unexpected
behavior... for as far as I can see aesthetics. (aesthetics
that I don't share, fwiw).

                Mike

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>